Original Recipe Podcast

Jeff McHugh • August 2, 2021

If it is your goal to do a podcast, simply whip out your mobile device, open one of the many podcast apps, and press “record.” For many, doing a podcast could be fulfilling for the host, but it often doesn’t attract listeners.

If it is your goal to do an original podcast  that people listen to , there are many factors to consider.

When I am approached by a company or an individual with an idea for a podcast I strive to be encouraging, to look at what is possible – and to educate them on a few basic realities.

Podcasting – like any media or entertainment platform – is a crowded battlefield with many casualties. Of all the available podcasts in the world today, 75% are no longer active according to  Podcast Industry insights. Many shows never make it to a second episode.

For initial conversations with aspiring podcasters, I try to guide them with simple start-up questions.

How will your show serve and entertain an audience?  Good shows are designed to entertain first and inform second. Information podcasts must offer relevant, fact-checked information – content that the listener already cares about — not what they  should  care about. If a show is extraordinarily funny, humor trumps everything. A red flag is when a company wants to “showcase our brand and services.” That is an infomercial, not a show.

  • Do you have an  episode plan  and  show plan ?
    • A show plan includes:
      • Frequency . Will the show post new episodes daily, weekly, monthly?  Make a schedule and stick to it. Shows must post like clockwork to retain their audience.
         
      • Multiple-episode content . How does episode one flow into episode two and then to episode three, carrying along as much of the audience as possible?
         
  • An episode plan includes:
    • A knockout setup . The first words spoken on the show must grab the audience’s attention.
       
    • Episode start.  Place the  best  content of the episode in the first five minutes, where podcasts lose 20-30% of their audience.
       
    • Episode end . Schedule the  second-best  content of the episode at the end, where the host can tease the audience into staying tuned.
    • Pattern disruptions . Good podcasts re-engage the audience with some kind of change every 2 ½ to 5 minutes. Change topics, shift hosts, bring in new guests, add benchmark features.
       
  • What is your business plan?
    Budget and account for these items:
    • How will you monetize the show? Advertisers? Subscribers? Client referrals?
       
    • Editing and distribution. Consider outsourcing to an excellent, affordable production company like  EditMyAudio.com  from our friend, Tessa Hall.
       
    • Audio: Microphones, soundproofing, etc. Cheap equipment sounds cheap.
       
    • Graphics: Your show’s thumbnail logo is a make-or-break factor in attracting first-time listeners. Invest in a great one.
       
    • Promotion: How will listeners find your show? Consider the cost of advertising on other podcasts.
       
  • Have you done a competitive review?  Studying what other podcasts in your genre are doing will help determine how your show needs to be different and how high to set the bar to compete.
    .
  • What are the stories you will tell?  Imagine that a person wants to start a wine podcast. Our advice is  stories, not stuff. Wine fans can get information about vintages, growing seasons, grape varietals, etc. from an app. A good wine podcast tells stories about interesting winemakers, how they began, life challenges and winery setbacks, and happy endings.

Photo by Kate Oseen on Unsplash

Share this article

Recent Posts

By Randy Lane • September 29, 2026
When I start coaching a show, talents often say:“Nobody calls anymore.” Or: “Listeners in this market don’t call radio shows.” My response is, “That’s interesting, because several of our shows get more calls than they need.” The difference isn’t necessarily the market. It’s often how the show invites people into the conversation.  Airing callers and text […]
By Randy Lane • September 21, 2026
Jerry Seinfeld wrote every episode of Seinfeld longhand, on a yellow legal pad, with a blue Bic pen. He still writes that way. He’s said the flashing cursor on a screen makes him anxious, like it’s asking, “So, whaddaya got?” Why Start With Pen and Paper?Writing by hand slows you down just enough for ideas to […]
By Randy Lane • September 15, 2026
In the era of loud, fast-talking announcer DJs, my radio mentor, Todd Wallace, asked my fellow DJs and me, “Would you talk to your neighbor over the back fence like a pukey DJ or just in natural conversation?” Of course we all said we’d talk to them conversationally. Todd concluded, “Talk to listeners on air like […]
Show More