When You Hate Your Own Show

Jeff McHugh • November 18, 2018

In 1972, the head of CBS television hated the most popular show on his own network.

All in the Family  was a controversial sitcom about bigot Archie Bunker. CBS president William S. Paley turned off his TV every Sunday to avoid seeing it.

All in the Family  was number one in Nielsen and is now considered some of the best TV ever made. Paley won by programming for the audience and not for himself.

Every on-air talent and every manager has a personal vision for their programming. But when you learn that your audience has a totally different preference, what will you compromise?

What if you love talking politics but doing so turns off your audience? Suppose your #1 feature is  War Of The Roses  but you dread every episode? What if pre-producing A+ benchmarks is more PPM-friendly, but you prefer that everything is live?

All successful entertainers have  something  in their show that they dislike, but they do it to win. Like a band playing hits that they are tired of because the audience still sings along.

Some broadcasters cannot let go of their favorite features, like the deejay in  Good Morning Vietnam  who played his polkas instead of the rock and roll that soldiers preferred.

Committing to serving the audience is your first step. Knowing what they want comes next. How do you know? Ask.

The most competitive broadcasting companies ask the audience through research and their answers help your show stay in touch with the times.

However, if your company does not have the financial strength to buy research, consider these alternatives:

Trade  – with a local research company. We once traded with Hatch Research to do a focus group on a show in St Louis.

Universities  – consumer research programs will sometimes do research as a student project.

Deep dive into Nielsen  – when the show vacations, do the ratings go up or down that week? Did you play more music or replay more A+ features?

Review digital statistics  – which of your podcasts are played through to the end? What social media posts get engagement?|

Listener panels  – solicit your P1 fans to give up an hour of their time and opinion in exchange for pizza and tickets.

Use social media  – post basic questions for your followers using survey tools.

Online surveys  – Google docs and Survey Monkey are easy and free.

Photo Credit:  flickr.com/photos/honou/

Share this article

Recent Posts

By Randy Lane • September 29, 2026
When I start coaching a show, talents often say:“Nobody calls anymore.” Or: “Listeners in this market don’t call radio shows.” My response is, “That’s interesting, because several of our shows get more calls than they need.” The difference isn’t necessarily the market. It’s often how the show invites people into the conversation.  Airing callers and text […]
By Randy Lane • September 21, 2026
Jerry Seinfeld wrote every episode of Seinfeld longhand, on a yellow legal pad, with a blue Bic pen. He still writes that way. He’s said the flashing cursor on a screen makes him anxious, like it’s asking, “So, whaddaya got?” Why Start With Pen and Paper?Writing by hand slows you down just enough for ideas to […]
By Randy Lane • September 15, 2026
In the era of loud, fast-talking announcer DJs, my radio mentor, Todd Wallace, asked my fellow DJs and me, “Would you talk to your neighbor over the back fence like a pukey DJ or just in natural conversation?” Of course we all said we’d talk to them conversationally. Todd concluded, “Talk to listeners on air like […]
Show More